Bully Victims (targets) treated like
Criminals
Ask any councilor, school
official or anyone in authority what the biggest problem they face when it
comes to bullying and they will usually tell you that kids won’t report it.
Their reasoning is that the kids don’t want to be a stool pigeon, or accused of
ratting out, or telling on someone. This may be valid in a very few cases, but
in most cases it’s NOT.
The real reason most victims
and families are reluctant to come forward is the fear of not being believed.
Frequently in bully situations, especially if the bully is a popular bully
which is the case most of the time, the parents of the victim have nothing more
than a sobbing bruised child with no witnesses, supporters or proof. The child
knows exactly who is doing this to them and can describe what is happening and
where, but that’s it. No evidence to support their claim. This creates a “my
word against theirs” situation. This imbalance is typical of bullying. No one
wants to be on the losing side so everyone supports the bully.
One study conducted by The Association of Chief Psychologists with Ontario School Boards says;
Why
does the victim not reveal that he/she is being harassed or beaten up
or whatever? The answer is, of course, that the victim is afraid of
retaliation from the bullies. But if we analyze that reasoning, it
really says that the victim does not believe that we, the adults, can
or will protect him. And why would a victim fear that we can't or won't
provide protection? Because we don't. And we don't, in part at least,
because our culture has immersed bullying in a mythology that says that
if a child is being bullied, especially a boy, adult intervention will
make matters worse.
Besides the mythology described
above, there is another cultural factor that mitigates against adults
taking action. As has been suggested in countless studies of
victimology, we tend to dislike victims. A consequence of this dislike
is that adults who discover a bullying situation, first tend to look
for evidence that the victim in fact caused the problem and brought the
bully's wrath upon himself. This is often clear from the
"interrogation" which greets children who approach adults for help:
"What did you do?";
"Did you say anything to those bigger boys?";
"Why were you playing in that area when you know that's where the big boys play?";
"Why did you wear your new shoes when you must have known they would tease you if you wore them?".
Such questions are unsettling in the
context of serious bullying. Their impact is even more disturbing when
we note their resemblance to questions often posed to other victims
subjected to blame, namely women reporting harassment or even rape:
"Did you know the man or talk to him?";
"Why were you in that part of town at night?";
"What were you wearing?";
"Were you drinking?".
This behaviour on the part of
authority figures serves to demonstrate to the victim that instead of
protection they might well get blamed for the very problem they are
reporting. The message is clear. Victims should find a way to solve the
problem themselves, or simply live with it.
The problem with our authorities, is their outdated archaic beliefs.
Investigators believe that good guys wear white and bad guys wear
black. If on arrival, the bullies don't look and act like bullies. The
authorities automatically type cast the people involved and draw
conclusions. When this
occurs, those in authority frequently ignore physical evidence and put
greater
weight on what the bully and the bully supporters say rather than view
things
objectively and fairly. In any bully/victim situation, the bully will usually be
surrounded by supporters. These supporters usually are both children
and adults
that will paint a picture of the bully as being anything but a bully.
They may
describe the bully as being friendly, entertaining and an all around
good
person. They will then immediately counter accuse the victim of being
the bully
and the attacker. They will say things about the victim that
isn’t true just to
discredit them. Child supporters of the bully will usually make up
stories
about how the victim is always bothering them and that they
aren’t doing
anything to the victim. Adult supporters of the bullies will usually
accuse the
victim and family of frequently making false claims, they will say the
victim is having mental problems, being abusive
etc. To help the bullies, the authorities may use a fake investigation
to
legitimize the bully’s version.
In the end, coming forward
with a bully complaint can and usually does make things much worse for the
victim and family. Once the authorities have decided that your complaint is
false, the bullying you were complaining about will seem insignificant to the
bullying you are about to deal with. After the complaint is dismissed by the
authorities, the bullies will probably wait a while and then launch a vicious
reprisal. Revenge will be on their minds and they will now plot ways to get
back at you to punish you for speaking up. Frequently the authorities will help
with the reprisal as they now view you as the problem. The attacks rarely come directly from the
original bully. Instead, the bullies will encourage their supporters to attack
the victim to draw attention away from the original source. The supporters of
the bullies will gossip about what happened and convince otherwise uninvolved
people to help with the reprisal. The original bully may no longer even know
who all the attackers are as the gossip will become distorted and the victim
and family will be painted as evil people
that need to be gotten rid of. Neighborhood
Bullying is the result.
What the authorities don’t
comprehend or are simply to slow to see, is the fact that many by-standers will
know the truth. They will watch and observe the events as they play out and see
the reprisal. They will then talk amongst themselves and realize that reporting
bullying is bad.
At a time when both the
parents and child need some comfort, understanding and a friendly person to
talk to, they find themselves being questioned in a police interrogation room,
threatened and intimidated. The original child victim is forgotten ignored and
left feeling worse than ever. Then everyone acts surprised and shocked when the
victim resorts to drug abuse, alcohol abuse or suicide to solve their
problem. It would be fair to say in a
case such as this that the authorities are responsible for the reprisal against
the victim and the consequences to the child.
The government at all levels
knows what to do. Information about the proper way to handle bullying complaint
is abundant.
See know your rights.
http://www.psepc-sppcc.gc.ca/res/cp/bully_12217-en.asp
Here is what the experts say we should expect.
If you are a leader of
an organization responsible for young people (e.g. a school principal or
manager of a sports team or other youth program)
- Listen
and respond to all complaints from youth, parents or adults responsible
for youth about bullying, even the
seemingly trivial ones such as name-calling. Consistency matters!
- Support
the adults who work directly with teens in their constructive approaches
to end bullying such as separating disruptive teens, increasing
supervision in bullying hot spots and placing vulnerable youth in positive
groups.
- Create
an effective anti-bullying policy in your organization that clearly sets
the limits on acceptable behaviour. Include meaningful consequences in the
policy to help teach the aggressive youth healthier ways of interacting.
- Allow
time for the policy to be reviewed and agreed upon by everyone (including teens).
- Ensure
the policy is consistently and
universally applied by all involved.
- Consider
how you treat others in the organization and how you allow others to treat
you. As a role model, your actions
and reactions can influence how youth relate to each other.
The NCPS wishes to acknowledge the support and
assistance of Drs. Pepler and Craig, through the Canadian Initiative for the
Prevention of Bullying, in the development of this document.
A few examples of what happens when you try to do something and come forward
with a bully complaint and the authorities call you a liar.
Fingerprinted_and_checked_for_DNA a victims story.
Think you have the right to protect your children? Think Again!
Bullying victims father denies assaulting bully part1
Father convicted for shaking bully part 2
Bullies attack and everyone makes excuses, but god help you if you as a victim dare to fight back.
Bully victim gets tired of teasing
Manitoba Child and Family Serviced issued this letter without ever speaking to the victim or family
CFS letter
When victims of bullying are treated like this, they have three choices
1. Stop complaining knowing the bullying will simply increase and life will become more and more miserable
2. Continue complaining knowing you will be called a liar and you and your family could be arrested
3. Suicide
Note: the same reasons for not reporting
bullying is usually found when crimes are committed. People believe that
reporting a crime such as a car break in, vandalism, assaults, theft etc. will
be received by a caring concerned law enforcement official. This is not the
case some times instead, you MAY be received with suspicion and the
police, government worker councilor or any other official will treat you like
you are lying and try to intimidate you. The experience usually is so poor that
it is unlikely that you would ever make another report of a crime or even get
involved as a witness ever again. You will then tell your family and friend
about your treatment and they too will be reluctant to report a problem. The
result is a reduction in complaints that government can use as spin for
the public.